Peter Capaldi’s time as the Twelfth Doctor in Doctor Who marked a period of significant change for the long-running series. Known for his intense and serious portrayal, Capaldi brought a different kind of energy to the Doctor, a character who has been played by many actors over the years, each bringing their unique interpretation. His run as the Doctor began in 2013 and continued until 2017, spanning three seasons and several special episodes.
Capaldi’s Doctor was a departure from the more light-hearted and youthful versions played by David Tennant and Matt Smith. He was older, gruffer, and often more introspective, with a complex personality that could shift from humorous to dark in a moment. His performance was lauded for its depth and range, making it challenging to pinpoint his single best episode. However, some episodes stand out more than others, either for their storytelling, Capaldi’s performance, or their impact on the series as a whole.
The Context of Capaldi’s Era
Before delving into Capaldi’s best episode, it’s essential to understand the context of his era. Doctor Who is a show that thrives on change. Every few years, the Doctor regenerates, leading to a new actor taking on the role and bringing their spin to the character. With each regeneration, the tone, style, and even the show’s direction can shift dramatically.
When Capaldi took over, Doctor Who was still under the guidance of showrunner Steven Moffat, who had been at the helm since 2010. Moffat is known for his intricate and sometimes convoluted storytelling, with episodes that often play with time, reality, and perception. Capaldi’s era was characterized by episodes that were darker and more philosophical, often exploring themes of identity, morality, and the consequences of the Doctor’s actions.
Capaldi’s Doctor was a more mature and world-weary figure. He was less concerned with being liked and more focused on doing what he believed was right, even if it meant making difficult or unpopular decisions. This was a Doctor who was grappling with his sense of self, his purpose, and the weight of his long life. This introspective and sometimes melancholic approach resonated with many fans, who appreciated the depth and complexity Capaldi brought to the role.
The Criteria for the Best Episode
Selecting the best episode from Capaldi’s tenure as the Doctor involves considering several factors. First, the episode’s narrative strength is crucial. Doctor Who is a show built on storytelling, and the best episodes are often those with compelling, well-constructed plots that engage the audience from start to finish.
Second, the portrayal of the Doctor in the episode is a key factor. Since Capaldi’s Doctor was known for his intense and nuanced performances, the best episodes are those where he was given the opportunity to showcase the full range of his acting abilities.
Finally, the episode’s impact on the series and its fans is significant. Some episodes leave a lasting impression because they change the course of the series, reveal important aspects of the Doctor’s character, or resonate deeply with the audience.
See also: Who Dies in The Good Doctor Season 6?
The Leading Contenders
Capaldi’s tenure includes several standout episodes that could be considered his best. Here are a few of the most notable ones:
Heaven Sent (Series 9, Episode 11)
Heaven Sent is often regarded as one of the finest episodes of Doctor Who, not just of Capaldi’s era but of the entire series. The episode is unique in that it features Capaldi’s Doctor almost entirely on his own, with no companion or significant supporting characters. This isolation allows for an intense focus on the Doctor’s character, his thoughts, and his determination to survive against impossible odds.
In Heaven Sent, the Doctor finds himself trapped in a mysterious castle that seems to be designed to torture him. The episode is essentially a one-man show, with Capaldi carrying the entire narrative. His performance is extraordinary, conveying the Doctor’s fear, anger, grief, and ultimately his unbreakable will to keep going. The episode’s structure is also noteworthy, with its use of time loops and the gradual revelation of the castle’s true purpose adding layers of complexity to the story.
Heaven Sent is a masterclass in acting and storytelling, and it’s a strong contender for Capaldi’s best episode. Its exploration of the Doctor’s psyche, combined with Capaldi’s powerful performance, makes it a standout moment in the series.
The Zygon Inversion (Series 9, Episode 8)
Another episode often cited as one of Capaldi’s best is The Zygon Inversion. This episode is part of a two-parter that deals with the Zygons, a race of shapeshifting aliens who have been living in secret on Earth. The story is an allegory for real-world issues like immigration, identity, and terrorism, with the Doctor caught in the middle of a conflict between humans and Zygons.
What makes The Zygon Inversion particularly memorable is a scene near the end where the Doctor delivers a passionate speech about the futility of war and the importance of finding peaceful solutions. This speech, often referred to as the “war speech,” is one of the most powerful moments in Capaldi’s run. It showcases his ability to convey deep emotion and conviction, and it has been widely praised by fans and critics alike.
The episode also explores the Doctor’s role as a mediator and peacemaker, highlighting his belief in the value of life and his determination to prevent violence whenever possible. The Zygon Inversion is a compelling, thought-provoking episode that demonstrates Capaldi’s strengths as the Doctor.
The Husbands of River Song (Christmas Special, 2015)
While many of Capaldi’s best episodes are intense and serious, The Husbands of River Song is a lighter, more humorous adventure. This Christmas special is significant because it features the Doctor’s final meeting with River Song, a character who has been an important part of the series since the Tenth Doctor’s era.
In this episode, Capaldi’s Doctor gets to show a different side of his personality, as he engages in banter and romantic tension with River. The episode is fun and fast-paced, with plenty of action and comedy. However, it also has moments of poignancy, particularly in the final scenes where the Doctor and River acknowledge that their time together is coming to an end.
The Husbands of River Song is a reminder that Capaldi’s Doctor is not just a serious, brooding figure but also someone who can be playful, charming, and affectionate. The episode is a fan favorite and an important part of Capaldi’s legacy as the Doctor.
World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls (Series 10, Episodes 11-12)
This two-part finale of Capaldi’s final season is another strong contender for his best episode. The story is a dark and emotional one, dealing with themes of loss, sacrifice, and the inevitability of change. It also marks the return of the Mondasian Cybermen, the original and most terrifying version of the iconic Doctor Who villains.
In these episodes, the Doctor faces one of his most difficult challenges yet, as he tries to save his friends and stop the Cybermen while knowing that his time is running out. Capaldi delivers a powerful performance, capturing the Doctor’s determination, sadness, and acceptance of his fate.
The finale also features a poignant farewell to Bill Potts, the Doctor’s companion, who undergoes a tragic transformation. The relationship between the Doctor and Bill is one of the highlights of Capaldi’s era, and these episodes give it a fitting and emotional conclusion.
World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls is a dramatic and memorable end to Capaldi’s time as the Doctor, and it encapsulates many of the themes and qualities that defined his era.
The Case for Heaven Sent
While all the episodes mentioned above are strong contenders, Heaven Sent stands out as Capaldi’s best episode for several reasons.
First, the episode is a showcase for Capaldi’s acting talent. With no other main characters to share the screen with, Capaldi carries the entire episode on his own. This allows him to explore the Doctor’s character in depth, portraying a wide range of emotions and showcasing the Doctor’s resilience and intelligence.
Second, the episode’s narrative structure is both innovative and engaging. The use of time loops and the gradual revelation of the castle’s purpose create a sense of tension and mystery that keeps the audience hooked from start to finish. The final twist, revealing the nature of the Doctor’s prison and the identity of his captors, is both surprising and satisfying.
Finally, Heaven Sent is a deeply philosophical episode that explores themes of death, memory, and the passage of time. The Doctor’s journey through the castle is symbolic of his broader journey through life, and the episode’s resolution emphasizes the idea that even in the face of insurmountable odds, the Doctor will never give up.
For these reasons, Heaven Sent is not only the best episode of Capaldi’s era but also one of the best episodes of Doctor Who as a whole.
Conclusion
Peter Capaldi’s tenure as the Doctor was marked by many standout episodes, each showcasing his unique interpretation of the iconic character. While there are several strong contenders for his best episode, Heaven Sent emerges as the clear winner due to its compelling narrative, Capaldi’s extraordinary performance, and its deep exploration of the Doctor’s character.
Doctor Who is a show that thrives on change, and Capaldi’s era was no exception. His portrayal of the Doctor was different from those that came before him, offering a more mature, complex, and sometimes darker version of the character. Heaven Sent encapsulates the best of what Capaldi brought to the role, making it his defining episode and a highlight of the series.
As fans continue to revisit Capaldi’s era, Heaven Sent remains a standout, a testament to the strength of both Capaldi’s performance and the storytelling that defined his time as the Doctor.
Related topic:
What Is The Best Tom Baker Episode Of Doctor Who?
How Many Episodes In The Good Doctor Season 4?
When Will Season 7 of The Good Doctor Be Released?