The connection between Harley Quinn and the Joker is one of the most iconic and controversial in comic book history. With the release of Todd Phillips’ Joker in 2019, many fans expected to see Harley Quinn make an appearance alongside the Clown Prince of Crime. However, Harley Quinn, who is often portrayed as the Joker’s companion and love interest, was notably absent from the movie. This article delves into why Harley Quinn was left out of Joker, how her relationship with the Joker has evolved in other media, and the broader implications of her exclusion from the 2019 film.
Introduction: Who is Harley Quinn?
Harley Quinn, also known as Dr. Harleen Quinzel, is a character created by Paul Dini and Bruce Timm. She first appeared in Batman: The Animated Series in 1992, becoming an instant hit. Initially introduced as a sidekick and love interest for the Joker, Harley quickly gained popularity due to her chaotic yet charismatic personality. Her character arc has evolved significantly over the years, transitioning from a submissive partner to a symbol of empowerment and independence.
The character’s origin story, which begins with her as a psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum who falls in love with the Joker, has been explored in comics, TV shows, and movies. In most versions, Harley is portrayed as someone who is manipulated and emotionally abused by the Joker, leading her down a path of crime and madness. Her journey from Dr. Harleen Quinzel to Harley Quinn is tragic, making her one of the most complex characters in the Batman universe.
Harley Quinn’s on-screen portrayals, particularly by Margot Robbie in the Suicide Squad (2016) and Birds of Prey (2020) films, have further cemented her status as a fan favorite. With her bright, chaotic energy, she provides a counterbalance to the darker, more sinister persona of the Joker.
Given the deep ties between Harley Quinn and the Joker in other media, many fans were curious about her absence from Todd Phillips’ Joker film, which was a gritty, character-driven exploration of the villain’s origin story.
Todd Phillips’ Joker: A Standalone Story
One of the key reasons why Harley Quinn did not appear in Todd Phillips’ Joker is that the film was designed as a standalone story, unconnected to the larger DC Extended Universe (DCEU). Phillips and lead actor Joaquin Phoenix wanted to create a character-driven narrative that focused solely on the Joker’s transformation from a failed comedian into the infamous villain.
The 2019 Joker film was not meant to be a traditional comic book movie filled with larger-than-life characters and action sequences. Instead, it was a gritty, psychological drama that drew inspiration from films like Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy. Set in a grim version of Gotham City during the early 1980s, the film followed Arthur Fleck (Joaquin Phoenix), a man suffering from mental illness, as he descended into madness and violence.
Unlike other portrayals of the Joker, which often position him as a mastermind or criminal genius, this version of the character is depicted as a tragic figure, shaped by a harsh, uncaring society. This more grounded take on the Joker meant that many of the comic book elements associated with him, including his relationship with Harley Quinn, were left out of the film.
Why Was Harley Quinn Excluded?
One of the primary reasons Harley Quinn was excluded from Joker was the filmmakers’ decision to focus entirely on the Joker’s character development. Todd Phillips wanted to explore the Joker’s origin story in a way that had never been done before, stripping the character of the familiar trappings of comic book lore. Harley Quinn, being such an integral part of the Joker’s story in other iterations, might have distracted from this central narrative.
The film was also intended to stand alone, separate from the larger continuity of the DC Comics universe. The Joker of the DCEU, portrayed by Jared Leto, has an established relationship with Harley Quinn (played by Margot Robbie). By leaving Harley Quinn out of this version of the story, Phillips and Phoenix were able to craft a more intimate and focused character study without the need to tie into other films or characters from the DCEU.
Additionally, the dynamic between Harley Quinn and the Joker is often portrayed as highly toxic and abusive, raising concerns about how such a relationship would fit into a film that was trying to offer a more nuanced, realistic portrayal of mental illness. Including Harley Quinn might have complicated the narrative or detracted from the film’s primary focus on Arthur Fleck’s internal struggles.
See also: How did the Joker die in the Dark Knight
The Evolution of Harley Quinn in Film and Media
Although Harley Quinn was absent from Joker, her presence in the DCEU and other media continues to grow. In 2016, Margot Robbie brought the character to life in Suicide Squad, a performance that was widely praised despite the film receiving mixed reviews. Robbie’s portrayal of Harley Quinn emphasized her independence and chaotic energy, setting her apart from the Joker while still acknowledging their toxic relationship.
In Birds of Prey (2020), Harley Quinn finally took center stage. The film explored her decision to break away from the Joker and find her own identity. This narrative arc marked a significant departure from earlier depictions of Harley Quinn, which often centered around her relationship with the Joker. By giving Harley her own story, Birds of Prey allowed the character to grow and evolve beyond her status as the Joker’s sidekick.
The evolution of Harley Quinn in film mirrors her growth in comic books and animated series, where she has gradually become a more independent and empowered character. In the 2019 animated series Harley Quinn, voiced by Kaley Cuoco, the character undergoes a similar transformation, breaking free from the Joker’s control and building her own criminal empire.
Potential Future Appearances: Will Harley Quinn Be in Joker Sequel?
Following the success of Joker, speculation has arisen about a possible sequel. Fans have wondered whether Harley Quinn might be introduced in the next installment, especially since the character’s popularity continues to soar. While nothing has been confirmed, there are several reasons why Harley Quinn could be a compelling addition to a potential sequel.
Exploring a New Dynamic: A sequel to Joker could explore the complex relationship between the Joker and Harley Quinn in a fresh way, possibly diverging from the toxic, abusive dynamic seen in other versions. If the filmmakers choose to depict Harley Quinn as a character who is equally damaged by society, this could create a more nuanced and empathetic portrayal of their bond.
Expanding the Joker’s World: The first Joker film was a tightly focused character study, but a sequel could broaden the scope of the story by introducing other key figures from the Joker’s life. Harley Quinn, being one of the most important characters in the Joker’s lore, would be a logical choice for this expansion.
Connecting to the Larger DC Universe: While the original Joker was a standalone film, a sequel could offer opportunities to connect with other characters from the DC Universe. Given the popularity of Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn, the filmmakers might be tempted to bring her into the mix to attract a wider audience.
However, it is equally possible that Harley Quinn will remain absent from any Joker sequels, given the filmmakers’ desire to keep the focus on the Joker as an individual character. As Todd Phillips has repeatedly emphasized, the 2019 Joker was meant to be a standalone film, and any future installments may continue to follow this approach.
The Absence of Harley Quinn: What It Means for the Film
The exclusion of Harley Quinn from Joker allowed the film to remain focused on its central theme: the descent of Arthur Fleck into madness. By avoiding the inclusion of other characters from the Joker’s comic book mythology, the filmmakers were able to present a more intimate and personal story.
This decision also allowed Joker to stand out from other comic book movies, which are often filled with interconnected characters and complex plotlines. By focusing solely on the Joker, the film was able to explore deeper themes related to mental illness, societal neglect, and the consequences of violence.
Harley Quinn’s absence also avoided the need to depict the toxic, abusive relationship that has defined much of her history with the Joker. While this relationship is an important part of both characters’ lore, it might have clashed with the more serious and grounded tone of Joker.
Conclusion
While Harley Quinn did not appear in Joker, her absence was a deliberate choice that served the film’s narrative goals. By focusing solely on the Joker’s origin story, the filmmakers were able to create a more nuanced and intimate portrait of the character.
However, with the ongoing popularity of Harley Quinn in both film and television, it is possible that she could make an appearance in future Joker films. Whether or not she appears, Harley Quinn remains a beloved and complex character whose evolution continues to captivate audiences.
Ultimately, Harley Quinn’s absence from Joker speaks to the film’s unique approach to the Joker’s character. By stripping away the more familiar elements of comic book lore, the filmmakers were able to craft a powerful and thought-provoking story that stands on its own. Harley Quinn may not have been in Joker, but her influence and legacy as a character continue to shape the world of Gotham City.
Related topic:
How Many Joker Movies Are There?
Will Batman Be In The New Joker Movie?
Who Played The Joker in the Joker Movie? [Revealed]