Since its debut in 2016, Stranger Things has captivated audiences worldwide with its nostalgic ’80s setting, supernatural mysteries, and a compelling cast of characters. The series, created by the Duffer Brothers, has successfully blended horror, science fiction, and heartfelt drama into a single cohesive narrative. Across its four seasons, Stranger Things has maintained a high standard of storytelling while introducing new characters, deeper mysteries, and emotional arcs that keep viewers coming back for more.
But which season stands out as the best? This question has sparked many debates among fans, with each season bringing something unique to the table. In this article, we will analyze the strengths and weaknesses of each season, looking at character development, plot progression, and how each installment contributes to the overall success of the show. By the end, we hope to determine which season can truly be called the best.
Season 1: The Beginning of an Iconic Show
Stranger Things Season 1 set the stage for everything to come. Premiering in July 2016, the first season introduced viewers to the fictional town of Hawkins, Indiana, and the strange events surrounding the disappearance of Will Byers. The plot of this season is tight and focuses on three major threads: the search for Will, the discovery of a strange girl named Eleven with supernatural powers, and the growing awareness that something far darker lurks beneath the surface of the town.
Storyline and Themes
Season 1 is a masterclass in building tension and mystery. The season is reminiscent of classic ’80s adventure movies like E.T. and The Goonies. At the same time, it introduces elements of horror inspired by Stephen King and John Carpenter. The small-town setting, combined with government conspiracies and otherworldly creatures, hooks viewers right from the start.
The main storyline follows Mike Wheeler, Dustin Henderson, and Lucas Sinclair as they search for their missing friend Will. Along the way, they meet Eleven, a girl with a shaved head and psychokinetic abilities who escapes from a secret government lab. Parallel to this, we witness Joyce Byers, Will’s frantic mother, who believes her son is communicating with her from another dimension.
What makes Season 1 so impactful is its sense of discovery. Each episode peels back another layer of mystery, leading to the revelation of the Upside Down—a dark, alternate dimension filled with monstrous creatures like the Demogorgon.
Characters and Relationships
The characters in Season 1 are immediately likable. Mike, Dustin, and Lucas form a strong trio of nerdy friends, while Eleven’s introduction adds an element of intrigue. Their interactions feel authentic, capturing the essence of childhood friendship. Joyce Byers (Winona Ryder) brings emotional weight to the show with her relentless search for her son, while Chief Jim Hopper (David Harbour) slowly emerges as the town’s unlikely hero.
Nancy Wheeler and Jonathan Byers also develop throughout the season, with Nancy evolving from a typical high school girl to a determined young woman who wants to uncover the truth about her friend Barb’s disappearance.
The Strengths of Season 1
Nostalgia and References: The season is filled with references to ‘80s pop culture, from Dungeons & Dragons to classic horror movies. This makes it appealing to both younger audiences and adults who grew up during that era.
Tight Narrative: With only eight episodes, the first season wastes no time. The plot is concise, and every character’s arc feels meaningful.
Introduction of the Upside Down: The concept of the Upside Down is both fascinating and terrifying. This alternate dimension provides the perfect backdrop for the horror elements of the show.
Weaknesses of Season 1
Limited Scope: While the first season does an excellent job of introducing the world and characters, its scope is relatively narrow. Much of the action takes place within Hawkins, and the larger mysteries of the Upside Down are only hinted at.
Season 2: Expanding the World of Hawkins
Following the massive success of Season 1, Stranger Things returned in 2017 with its highly anticipated second season. Season 2 picks up nearly a year after the events of the first season, as the town of Hawkins attempts to move on from the traumatic events involving Will’s disappearance and the discovery of the Upside Down.
Storyline and Themes
Season 2 builds upon the foundations laid in the first season, introducing new characters and expanding the show’s mythology. Will Byers, now back from the Upside Down, is struggling with visions of a dark creature known as the Mind Flayer. As Will’s condition worsens, the characters realize that the threat from the Upside Down is far from over.
The season also introduces new characters like Max Mayfield, a tomboyish skater who quickly becomes part of the group, and her older stepbrother Billy Hargrove, who adds tension with his antagonistic behavior. Season 2 delves deeper into government conspiracies and explores the larger implications of the Upside Down.
Characters and Relationships
One of the standout elements of Season 2 is the character development. Will Byers, who was largely absent in the first season, takes center stage as the show explores the psychological trauma he suffered in the Upside Down. His connection to the Mind Flayer becomes a central plot point, giving actor Noah Schnapp a chance to shine.
Meanwhile, Eleven embarks on her own journey of self-discovery. Separated from the main group for much of the season, she learns more about her origins and her connection to other children who were experimented on by Dr. Brenner. This culminates in the controversial Episode 7, where Eleven meets Kali, another girl with powers. This episode divided fans but added an interesting layer to Eleven’s character arc.
The dynamics between the characters also evolve. Dustin and Steve Harrington form an unlikely friendship, which has since become one of the highlights of the series. Steve transitions from a somewhat shallow character into a fan-favorite “babysitter” figure.
The Strengths of Season 2
Character Growth: Season 2 does an excellent job of developing the characters introduced in the first season. Steve, in particular, undergoes significant growth, transforming from a high school jerk into a protective figure for the younger kids.
The Mind Flayer: The introduction of the Mind Flayer raises the stakes. Unlike the Demogorgon, which was more of a physical threat, the Mind Flayer is a cerebral villain, capable of manipulating and possessing people.
Expansion of the Upside Down: We get a deeper look into the Upside Down, learning more about its creatures and how it connects to our world.
Weaknesses of Season 2
Episode 7: The decision to separate Eleven from the main group for an entire episode was a controversial one. While it adds depth to her character, many fans felt it slowed down the momentum of the main storyline.
Pacing: With nine episodes, Season 2 occasionally feels slower than its predecessor. Some subplots, like Dustin’s relationship with Dart (a baby Demogorgon), may not have been necessary.
See also: 10 Best Characters in Stranger Things
Season 3: A New Threat Emerges
Season 3 of Stranger Things arrived in July 2019, and it was perhaps the most action-packed season yet. The third season is set in the summer of 1985, and the town of Hawkins has a new centerpiece: the Starcourt Mall. As the kids enjoy their summer break, a new threat from the Upside Down begins to surface, and it becomes clear that the Mind Flayer is not done with Hawkins yet.
Storyline and Themes
The third season introduces the concept of Russian interference, as a secret Soviet base beneath Hawkins is revealed to be conducting experiments to open a gateway to the Upside Down. This adds a new Cold War-era tension to the series, blending real-world history with the show’s fictional elements.
The return of the Mind Flayer is a key plot point, as it begins to take control of human hosts, including Billy Hargrove. The possession of Billy leads to some of the most chilling and emotional moments in the series, as the characters struggle to save him while battling the increasingly powerful Mind Flayer.
Season 3 also amps up the action, with several intense battle sequences, including a climactic showdown at the Starcourt Mall. The show’s signature blend of horror, science fiction, and heartfelt drama remains strong, but the emphasis on spectacle and action is more pronounced in this season.
Characters and Relationships
Season 3 sees the kids entering their teenage years, and with that comes new challenges in their relationships. Mike and Eleven are now officially dating, much to Hopper’s dismay, while Lucas and Max continue their relationship. Dustin, who has spent the summer at a science camp, returns with a new girlfriend, Suzie, who plays a key role in one of the most memorable moments of the season: the NeverEnding Story duet.
The friendship between Steve and Dustin continues to be a highlight, and they are joined by a new character, Robin Buckley, who works with Steve at the Scoops Ahoy ice cream shop. Robin quickly becomes a fan-favorite character, thanks to her wit and chemistry with Steve.
Billy’s role as the main antagonist adds an emotional layer to the season. While he was a bully in Season 2, Season 3 delves into his troubled past, making his eventual redemption more impactful.
The Strengths of Season 3
Action and Spectacle: Season 3 is the most visually impressive season, with bigger set pieces and more intense action scenes. The battle at Starcourt Mall is a standout moment.
Character Relationships: The friendships and romances between the characters continue to evolve in meaningful ways. Steve and Robin’s friendship, in particular, is a refreshing addition to the show.
Billy’s Redemption: Billy’s arc is one of the most emotional aspects of the season. His final sacrifice adds a tragic element to his character and gives the season a poignant conclusion.
Weaknesses of Season 3
Overreliance on Action: While the action is exciting, some fans felt that Season 3 sacrificed the slower, more atmospheric tension of the earlier seasons in favor of spectacle.
Russian Plotline: The introduction of the Russian subplot was divisive. Some viewers enjoyed the Cold War-inspired storyline, while others found it too far-fetched for the show’s grounded roots.
Season 4: The Darkest Season Yet
After a long hiatus, Stranger Things returned in 2022 with its fourth season. Season 4 is the darkest and most ambitious season of the series so far, with multiple storylines unfolding across different locations, including Hawkins, California, and even Russia.
Storyline and Themes
Season 4 introduces a new villain, Vecna, a powerful being from the Upside Down who begins to target Hawkins’ teenagers. The season explores Vecna’s origins, revealing a connection to Eleven’s past and the experiments conducted by Dr. Brenner.
The season is split into several major plotlines. In Hawkins, Dustin, Lucas, and the others try to unravel the mystery of Vecna, while Eleven embarks on a journey to regain her powers. Meanwhile, Hopper is revealed to be alive, imprisoned in a Russian labor camp, and Joyce and Murray set out to rescue him.
Season 4 also delves deeper into the psychological horror elements of the series, with Vecna’s ability to prey on the trauma and guilt of his victims adding a new layer of terror. The season’s darker tone and more mature themes reflect the growing maturity of the characters themselves.
Characters and Relationships
Season 4 brings significant character development, particularly for Max, who becomes one of Vecna’s targets. Her struggle with guilt over Billy’s death leads to some of the most emotional moments of the season, including a standout sequence set to Kate Bush’s Running Up That Hill.
Eleven’s journey is also central to the season, as she confronts her past and her role in creating Vecna. Meanwhile, the friendship between Steve, Robin, and Dustin continues to provide comic relief amidst the darker tone of the season.
Hopper’s storyline in Russia offers a different kind of action, as he attempts to survive the brutal conditions of the labor camp and make his way back to Hawkins.
The Strengths of Season 4
Vecna as a Villain: Vecna is one of the most terrifying and well-developed villains in the series. His connection to Eleven’s past adds depth to his character, and his powers make him a formidable threat.
Character Development: Max’s arc is a standout, with her emotional journey providing some of the season’s most powerful moments. Eleven’s confrontation with her past also adds layers to her character.
Darker Tone: The shift towards more mature and darker themes works well in Season 4, reflecting the characters’ growth and the escalating stakes.
Weaknesses of Season 4
Pacing Issues: With multiple plotlines unfolding across different locations, Season 4 can feel disjointed at times. Some fans felt that certain subplots, particularly the Russia storyline, slowed down the main narrative.
Longer Episodes: Season 4 features some of the longest episodes of the series, with some episodes exceeding 90 minutes. While this allows for more character development, it can also lead to pacing problems.
Conclusion
Each season of Stranger Things offers something unique, making it difficult to declare one season as definitively the best. Season 1 stands out for its tight narrative and sense of mystery, while Season 2 expands the world and deepens the character arcs. Season 3 brings action and spectacle, while Season 4 pushes the show into darker, more mature territory.
Ultimately, the best season may come down to personal preference. Fans who love the nostalgic, small-town mystery might favor Season 1, while those who enjoy larger stakes and more character-driven drama might prefer Season 4. However, if we had to choose, Season 4’s darker tone, ambitious storytelling, and the introduction of Vecna as a villain make it a strong contender for the title of the best season.
Stranger Things continues to evolve, and with a fifth and final season on the horizon, the show’s legacy is far from over.
Related topic:
When Is the Last Season of Stranger Things?
Is Stranger Things Scary for 12-Year-Olds?
The Best Episode of Stranger Things