As Virgin River gears up for its seventh season, fans are debating whether the beloved Netflix drama can be outshined by another rising sensation—Sweet Magnolias.
The long-running romantic drama, starring Alexandra Breckenridge as Mel Monroe and Martin Henderson as Jack Sheridan, has cemented its place as Netflix’s longest-running English-language series. However, the fourth season of Sweet Magnolias has rekindled interest in the South Carolina-based drama, leaving many viewers eager for confirmation of a fifth season.
The series follows the lives of three close friends—Maddie Townsend (JoAnna Garcia Swisher), Dana Sue Sullivan (Brooke Elliott), and Helen Decatur (Heather Headley)—as they navigate love, family, and career challenges. Its growing fan base has sparked debates on whether it surpasses Virgin River in storytelling and emotional depth.
A Reddit discussion posed the question: “Which is better, Sweet Magnolias or Virgin River?” Responses were mixed, with one fan stating, “Personally, I prefer Sweet Magnolias, but that’s not saying it’s objectively better. I just love the girlfriend group dynamic.”
Others remained loyal to Virgin River, with a user writing, “Virgin River for the win! Both shows capture the small-town charm, but the scenery in Virgin River is breathtaking.” Another countered, “I feel like the drama in Sweet Magnolias is less self-inflicted and makes more sense. The show also balances different age groups well, with seniors in Virgin River and teenagers in Sweet Magnolias.”
On social media platform X (formerly Twitter), the debate seemed to favor Sweet Magnolias, with one viewer admitting, “I love both, but I started watching Sweet Magnolias first, so it holds a special place in my heart. It just feels cozier.” Others agreed, expressing a preference for the warmth and relatability of Sweet Magnolias.
While the battle between the two dramas continues, Sweet Magnolias appears to be gaining momentum. With four seasons available and a potential fifth on the horizon, it might just be the perfect binge-watch before Virgin River returns.
Related topics:
Randle In New ‘Secret Competition’ Piano TV Series
Netflix Greenlights Live-Action “Scooby-Doo” Series
Apple TV+’s ‘Side Quest’ : A Fun, Unpredictable Anthology