“The Good Doctor” is a popular American medical drama that has captured the hearts of millions with its compelling storylines and the unique perspective it brings to the medical genre. What many fans may not know is that the show is based on a South Korean series of the same name. This article will delve into the origins of the American version, exploring the Korean show it is based on, and highlighting the key elements that have contributed to its success.
Origins of the American “The Good Doctor”
Development and Adaptation
The American version of “The Good Doctor” was developed by David Shore, the creator of the hit medical drama “House.” The show premiered on ABC in September 2017. The story follows Dr. Shaun Murphy, a young surgical resident with autism and savant syndrome, as he navigates the complexities of medical practice and interpersonal relationships at the prestigious San Jose St. Bonaventure Hospital.
Concept and Themes
The central concept of the series revolves around Shaun Murphy’s exceptional medical abilities and his struggles with social interactions. The show addresses themes of acceptance, the challenges faced by individuals with autism, and the dynamics of a high-pressure medical environment. These themes are rooted in the original Korean series, providing a unique perspective on the medical drama genre.
The South Korean “Good Doctor”
Overview of the Korean Series
The South Korean series “Good Doctor” (Korean: 굿 닥터) aired on KBS2 from August to October 2013. Created by Park Jae-bum, the show stars Joo Won as Park Si-on, a young surgical resident with autism and savant syndrome. The series was highly acclaimed for its sensitive portrayal of autism and its engaging storyline.
Plot Summary
The Korean “Good Doctor” follows Park Si-on, who, despite his incredible talent and photographic memory, faces significant challenges due to his developmental disorder. The series explores his journey as he strives to become a pediatric surgeon, overcoming prejudice and proving his worth to his colleagues and superiors. The show also delves into his personal growth, relationships, and the impact of his unique perspective on his approach to medicine.
Character Comparisons
Park Si-on vs. Shaun Murphy
Park Si-on: Portrayed by Joo Won, Park Si-on is a brilliant medical genius with a deep passion for pediatric surgery. His character is characterized by his innocence, honesty, and unwavering dedication to saving lives.
Shaun Murphy: Played by Freddie Highmore, Shaun Murphy mirrors Park Si-on’s medical prowess and social struggles. Highmore’s portrayal emphasizes Shaun’s vulnerability, resilience, and determination to succeed despite the odds.
Supporting Characters
Yoon Seo (Korean) vs. Claire Browne (American): Yoon Seo, played by Moon Chae-won, is a compassionate and supportive colleague who believes in Si-on’s potential. In the American version, Claire Browne, portrayed by Antonia Thomas, plays a similar role, providing emotional support and advocating for Shaun.
Kim Do-han (Korean) vs. Neil Melendez (American): Kim Do-han, acted by Joo Sang-wook, is a skilled and stern surgeon who initially doubts Si-on’s abilities. Neil Melendez, played by Nicholas Gonzalez, fulfills this role in the American series, exhibiting a similar blend of skepticism and eventual respect for Shaun’s talents.
See also: Who Is Dr Han In The Good Doctor?
Cultural Adaptation and Differences
Cultural Context
The adaptation of “Good Doctor” from Korean to American television involved significant cultural adjustments to resonate with the target audience. The Korean series is deeply rooted in South Korean culture, addressing societal attitudes towards disability, hierarchy in the workplace, and familial relationships. The American version, while maintaining the core themes, adapts these elements to fit the cultural landscape of the United States.
Medical Practices and Settings
Korean Healthcare System: The original series reflects the structure and practices of the South Korean healthcare system, with specific references to local medical protocols and hospital administration.
American Healthcare System: The adaptation incorporates aspects of the American healthcare system, including the hierarchical structure of medical residency programs, insurance-related issues, and the diversity of medical staff.
Narrative Style and Tone
Korean Drama Aesthetics: Korean dramas are known for their melodramatic elements, emotional depth, and intricate character development. “Good Doctor” incorporates these features, creating a heartfelt and poignant narrative.
American Drama Approach: The American version balances drama with moments of levity and procedural elements, focusing on medical cases and ethical dilemmas. The tone is often more direct and fast-paced, catering to Western audiences’ preferences.
Impact and Reception
Critical Acclaim
Both versions of “The Good Doctor” received critical acclaim for their portrayal of autism and their engaging storytelling.
Korean Series: The Korean “Good Doctor” was praised for its sensitive depiction of autism, with Joo Won’s performance earning widespread recognition. The series also garnered several awards, including the Grand Prize at the 2013 KBS Drama Awards.
American Series: The American adaptation was similarly well-received, with Freddie Highmore’s portrayal of Shaun Murphy earning critical acclaim and multiple award nominations. The show has been commended for raising awareness about autism and for its compelling characters and storylines.
Audience Reception
The success of both series can be attributed to their relatable characters, emotional depth, and thought-provoking themes.
Korean Audience: The Korean series resonated with viewers for its heartfelt storytelling and the relatable struggles of its protagonist. It achieved high viewership ratings and maintained a strong fanbase.
American Audience: The American version struck a chord with audiences for its unique perspective on the medical drama genre and its portrayal of a protagonist with autism. The show has maintained strong ratings and a loyal following since its premiere.
Legacy and Influence
Influence on Autism Representation
Both versions of “The Good Doctor” have contributed significantly to the representation of autism in popular media.
Awareness and Understanding: By depicting a protagonist with autism and savant syndrome, the series has helped raise awareness and foster a better understanding of the challenges faced by individuals on the autism spectrum. The shows highlight the importance of acceptance, inclusion, and support for neurodiverse individuals.
Inspiration and Empowerment: The character of Park Si-on/Shaun Murphy serves as an inspiration for many, demonstrating that individuals with autism can achieve great success and make meaningful contributions to society. The series has empowered viewers to embrace diversity and challenge societal prejudices.
Impact on Medical Dramas
The success of “The Good Doctor” has influenced the medical drama genre, encouraging more diverse and inclusive storytelling.
Innovative Storytelling: Both the Korean and American versions have introduced innovative storytelling techniques, focusing on the personal and professional growth of a protagonist with autism. This approach has set a new standard for character-driven narratives in medical dramas.
Global Reach: The international success of “The Good Doctor” has paved the way for other Korean dramas to be adapted for global audiences. It has highlighted the potential for cross-cultural storytelling and the universal appeal of well-crafted narratives.
Conclusion
The American “The Good Doctor” is a testament to the enduring appeal and impact of its Korean predecessor. By adapting the story of Park Si-on into the journey of Shaun Murphy, the series has brought the themes of autism, acceptance, and resilience to a global audience. Both versions of “The Good Doctor” continue to inspire, educate, and entertain viewers, demonstrating the power of inclusive storytelling and the importance of diverse representation in media.
Related topics:
Who Is Carly in The Good Doctor? [Revealed]
Why Is The Good Doctor Not On TV Tonight?
Will The Good Doctor Season 4 Be On Netflix?