Designated Survivor, the American political thriller starring Kiefer Sutherland, captivated audiences with its intense drama and complex characters. Over three seasons, the show explored political intrigue, terrorism, and personal struggles within the highest office in the United States. Each season of Designated Survivor had its unique strengths and weaknesses, leading to much debate among fans about which season was the best. In this article, we will analyze each season in detail, considering plot development, character arcs, and audience reception, to determine which season stands out as the best.
Season 1: A Thrilling Introduction
Overview of Season 1
Season 1 of Designated Survivor premiered on September 21, 2016, and introduced viewers to Tom Kirkman, the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, who suddenly becomes President of the United States after a catastrophic attack on the Capitol kills everyone above him in the presidential line of succession. The season focuses on Kirkman’s unexpected rise to power, the challenges he faces as an unprepared leader, and the ongoing investigation into the attack.
Key Elements of Season 1
Plot Development: The first season is heavily focused on the mystery of the Capitol attack. As Kirkman struggles to stabilize the government, the storyline delves into conspiracy theories, political backstabbing, and the search for the mastermind behind the attack.
Character Arcs: Season 1 did an excellent job of introducing and developing the core characters. Tom Kirkman’s transformation from a political outsider to a capable leader is compelling, and the supporting characters, such as FBI Agent Hannah Wells and Chief of Staff Aaron Shore, add depth to the narrative.
Political Intrigue: The series excels in creating a tense political atmosphere, with Kirkman navigating crises both domestic and international. The tension between Kirkman’s idealism and the harsh realities of politics is a central theme.
Critical Reception: Season 1 was well-received by critics and audiences alike. The show’s unique premise and Sutherland’s performance as Kirkman were widely praised. The season maintained high viewership numbers and was lauded for its gripping plot and strong character development.
Strengths of Season 1
Compelling Storyline: The mystery surrounding the Capitol attack is one of the strongest aspects of the season, keeping viewers on the edge of their seats.
Character Development: Tom Kirkman’s journey from an inexperienced politician to a confident leader is a highlight of the show.
Strong Performances: Kiefer Sutherland’s portrayal of Kirkman, along with solid performances from the supporting cast, elevated the show’s dramatic impact.
Weaknesses of Season 1
Pacing Issues: Some critics noted that the pacing of Season 1 was uneven, with certain episodes feeling slow compared to others.
Overreliance on Cliffhangers: While cliffhangers are a staple of thriller series, some viewers felt that Season 1 relied too heavily on them, sometimes sacrificing deeper character development in the process.
Conclusion on Season 1
Season 1 of Designated Survivor set a high standard for the series. Its combination of political drama, mystery, and strong character arcs made it a memorable introduction to the world of Tom Kirkman. For many fans, Season 1 remains the quintessential season of the show, thanks to its engaging plot and the novelty of its premise.
Season 2: Expanding the World
Overview of Season 2
Season 2 of Designated Survivor premiered on September 27, 2017, and continued to explore the challenges faced by President Tom Kirkman. With the immediate threat of the Capitol attack behind him, Kirkman now has to focus on governing the country and addressing both domestic and international crises. The season also delves deeper into Kirkman’s personal life and the toll that the presidency takes on him and his family.
Key Elements of Season 2
Plot Development: Season 2 shifts its focus from the conspiracy-driven plot of the first season to broader political issues. The season addresses topics such as terrorism, cyberattacks, and foreign diplomacy, reflecting the complexities of being the leader of the free world.
Character Arcs: Season 2 continues to develop the characters introduced in the first season while also introducing new ones. The dynamics between Kirkman and his team, as well as his relationship with his family, are central to the narrative.
Political Themes: The second season delves into more traditional political drama, exploring the challenges of governance, the role of the media, and the balance between national security and personal freedoms.
Critical Reception: Season 2 received mixed reviews from critics. While some praised the show for expanding its scope and tackling relevant political issues, others felt that the season lacked the tight narrative focus of the first season. The viewership also saw a decline, indicating that some fans were less engaged with the new direction of the series.
Strengths of Season 2
Broader Scope: Season 2’s exploration of a wider range of political issues added depth to the show’s portrayal of the presidency.
Character Development: The season continues to flesh out the main characters, particularly Tom Kirkman, as he grapples with the responsibilities of his office and the personal sacrifices it entails.
Topical Relevance: The season’s focus on contemporary political issues, such as cyber threats and international relations, made it relevant and thought-provoking.
Weaknesses of Season 2
Lack of a Central Plotline: The shift away from the conspiracy-driven plot of Season 1 led to a less cohesive narrative, with some episodes feeling more like standalone stories rather than part of a larger arc.
Inconsistent Pacing: As with the first season, some viewers felt that the pacing of Season 2 was uneven, with certain plotlines dragging while others were rushed.
Diminished Tension: Without the overarching mystery of the Capitol attack, the season lacked the same level of suspense and urgency that made Season 1 so compelling.
Conclusion on Season 2
Season 2 of Designated Survivor represents a shift in the show’s focus, moving away from the high-stakes conspiracy of the first season to a broader exploration of the challenges of the presidency. While this season offered more character depth and tackled relevant political issues, it struggled to maintain the same level of tension and narrative cohesion. For viewers who appreciated the political drama and character development, Season 2 provided a satisfying continuation of the story, but it lacked the intensity that defined the first season.
See also: Is There a Spin-Off to Designated Survivor?
Season 3: A Darker Turn
Overview of Season 3
Season 3 of Designated Survivor premiered on June 7, 2019, on Netflix, after the show was canceled by ABC and subsequently picked up by the streaming giant. This season marked a significant shift in tone and content, with a darker, more mature approach to the story. The season focuses on Kirkman’s re-election campaign, exploring the moral and ethical dilemmas he faces as he strives to remain in power.
Key Elements of Season 3
Plot Development: Season 3 centers on Tom Kirkman’s bid for re-election and the political machinations that come with it. The season explores issues such as campaign finance, voter manipulation, and the personal cost of political ambition.
Character Arcs: The third season delves deeper into the personal lives of the characters, particularly Kirkman, who faces difficult choices that challenge his integrity and values. The season also introduces new characters who play crucial roles in the campaign.
Darker Themes: The move to Netflix allowed the show to tackle darker and more mature themes, including mental health, drug addiction, and the ethical compromises of politics. The tone of the season is noticeably more somber, reflecting the pressures of the re-election campaign.
Critical Reception: Season 3 received mixed to positive reviews, with some praising the show’s darker tone and more complex narrative, while others criticized the season for straying too far from the show’s original premise. The move to Netflix also brought changes in the show’s format, including shorter episodes and more explicit content, which received mixed reactions from fans.
Strengths of Season 3
Darker and More Mature Tone: The shift to a darker, more adult-oriented narrative allowed for deeper exploration of the characters and the ethical dilemmas they face.
Complex Character Development: Season 3 presents a more nuanced portrayal of Tom Kirkman, showing the toll that the presidency takes on him and the difficult choices he must make to stay in power.
Relevant Themes: The season’s focus on contemporary political issues, such as election integrity and the influence of money in politics, added depth to the narrative and made it more relevant to current events.
Weaknesses of Season 3
Deviation from Original Premise: Some fans were disappointed by the shift away from the thriller elements that defined the first season, feeling that the show had lost its original identity.
Shorter Season: With only 10 episodes, Season 3 felt rushed at times, with certain plotlines and character arcs not receiving the same level of development as in previous seasons.
Mixed Reception to New Format: The move to Netflix allowed for more explicit content and a darker tone, which was not universally well-received by the show’s original fanbase.
Conclusion on Season 3
Season 3 of Designated Survivor marked a significant departure from the show’s earlier seasons, with a darker tone and more complex narrative. While some fans appreciated the shift to a more mature and nuanced exploration of politics, others felt that the season strayed too far from the elements that made the show popular in the first place. Despite its strengths in character development and thematic relevance, Season 3’s deviation from the show’s original premise left some viewers feeling dissatisfied.
Final Verdict: Which Season is the Best?
Evaluating the Strengths of Each Season
Season 1: The first season of Designated Survivor stands out for its compelling premise, tight narrative, and strong character development. The mystery of the Capitol attack provided a gripping storyline that kept viewers engaged from start to finish. For many fans, Season 1 remains the best because of its balance between political drama and thriller elements.
Season 2: Season 2 expanded the show’s scope, exploring a wider range of political issues and providing deeper character development. However, the lack of a central plotline and inconsistent pacing made it less cohesive than the first season. While it offered a more in-depth look at the challenges of the presidency, it lacked the intensity and suspense of Season 1.
Season 3: Season 3 took the show in a darker and more mature direction, focusing on the complexities of a re-election campaign and the ethical dilemmas of politics. While it offered a more nuanced portrayal of Tom Kirkman and tackled relevant contemporary issues, the shift away from the show’s original premise and the shorter season left some fans feeling disappointed.
Which Season Stands Out?
While each season of Designated Survivor has its unique strengths, Season 1 is often regarded as the best season of the show. Its combination of a compelling central mystery, strong character development, and a perfect balance between political drama and thriller elements made it a standout season. Season 1’s gripping storyline and the novelty of its premise set a high bar for the series, one that the subsequent seasons struggled to meet in the same way.
Conclusion
Designated Survivor remains a memorable political thriller that captivated audiences with its intense drama and complex characters. While all three seasons offered something different to viewers, Season 1 is widely considered the best due to its strong narrative focus, engaging plot, and the successful introduction of a world where an ordinary man becomes the leader of the free world. Whether you are a fan of political drama or conspiracy thrillers, Season 1 of Designated Survivor is a must-watch and continues to be the high point of the series.
Related topic:
Is Designated Survivor a Good Show? [Revealed]
Did Designated Survivor Win Any Awards?