In the world of cinematic universes, audiences are always eager to know whether various movies are connected. This is particularly true when it comes to popular films featuring legendary creatures like King Kong. Two of the most talked-about movies in this regard are King Kong (2005) and Kong: Skull Island (2017). These films both explore the story of the iconic giant ape, but are they related? Let’s examine the connections and differences between these two films to determine whether they share a common narrative or exist in separate universes.
The Storylines: King Kong (2005) vs. Skull Island
To understand if these films are related, we must first look at their individual storylines.
King Kong (2005)
Directed by Peter Jackson, King Kong (2005) is a modern remake of the classic 1933 King Kong film. It stays faithful to the original plot: a film crew travels to Skull Island, an uncharted territory, in search of adventure and exotic locations. There, they encounter Kong, a massive gorilla-like creature. The crew captures him and brings him back to New York, where Kong eventually meets his tragic end after climbing the Empire State Building.
Peter Jackson’s version adds depth to Kong’s character, portraying him not just as a monster, but as a tragic figure with emotional complexity. His connection with Ann Darrow (played by Naomi Watts), the film’s heroine, becomes a central theme. The movie showcases Kong’s protective nature toward her, adding layers of humanity to the otherwise titanic creature.
The film is set in 1933, directly aligning with the time of the original. It is a standalone piece that retells the King Kong story for a modern audience.
Kong: Skull Island (2017)
Kong: Skull Island, directed by Jordan Vogt-Roberts, takes a different approach. While it still takes place on Skull Island, the film is set in 1973, after the Vietnam War. The plot centers around a government-funded expedition to explore Skull Island, which is believed to be rich in resources and untouched by human civilization. The crew, including scientists, soldiers, and a photojournalist, soon encounters Kong, who is the island’s protector against other dangerous creatures.
Unlike the 2005 film, Skull Island does not focus on Kong’s capture or eventual death in New York. Instead, it presents him as the apex predator of his environment, where he maintains balance by defending the island from giant creatures, particularly the Skullcrawlers. The film positions Kong as a powerful guardian figure, hinting at his future importance in the broader MonsterVerse franchise.
Different Origins and Timelines
One of the most significant differences between King Kong (2005) and Kong: Skull Island is their origin stories and timelines.
Peter Jackson’s King Kong is set in the 1930s and directly pays homage to the original 1933 film. The setting is nostalgic, with a strong emphasis on period-accurate details. Kong is depicted as a once-feared god-like creature who becomes misunderstood when brought to the modern world. The film’s tone is grand and tragic, focusing on Kong’s relationship with Ann Darrow and his ultimate downfall.
On the other hand, Skull Island shifts the narrative to the 1970s, during the post-Vietnam era. This change in setting allows the filmmakers to incorporate themes of war, military intervention, and environmentalism. The characters in Skull Island are soldiers, scientists, and civilians exploring unknown territories for different reasons. Kong is not misunderstood or tragically killed; he is a king in his own right, ruling over Skull Island and maintaining peace on the island.
The two films offer vastly different interpretations of the same creature, but these differences are not just thematic — they also reflect a conscious decision to separate the two films in terms of storytelling and universe building.
Connections Between the Films
Despite these differences, are there any connections between King Kong (2005) and Kong: Skull Island?
The short answer is no — they are not directly related. However, there are thematic similarities, and they share a common source: the iconic 1933 King Kong. Both films draw inspiration from the same source material, but they are ultimately separate interpretations of the Kong mythos.
The MonsterVerse
Kong: Skull Island is part of Legendary Entertainment’s MonsterVerse, a shared cinematic universe that includes other films like Godzilla (2014), Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019), and Godzilla vs. Kong (2021). This series of films connects giant creatures from different parts of the world, creating a cohesive universe where Kong and Godzilla coexist. In this sense, Skull Island is not just a standalone film, but part of a larger narrative that ties into future movies.
Peter Jackson’s King Kong is not part of this universe. It is a self-contained story with no plans for sequels or connections to other giant monster films. The tone, setting, and narrative of King Kong (2005) make it clear that it was designed to be a tribute to the classic tale, rather than a jumping-off point for future films.
Skull Island as a Common Setting
One of the few things the two films have in common is the setting: Skull Island. In both movies, Skull Island is depicted as a remote and dangerous place inhabited by gigantic creatures, with Kong being the most powerful among them. However, the island’s portrayal differs.
In King Kong (2005), Skull Island is shrouded in mystery and danger. It’s an ancient place where creatures from a lost era still roam. The island’s inhabitants, both human and animal, are menacing, adding to the perilous environment. The movie presents Skull Island as a forgotten world, out of sync with modern civilization.
Kong: Skull Island, meanwhile, offers a slightly different perspective. The island is still dangerous, but the focus is on its ecosystem, with Kong being its central protector. The 2017 film goes deeper into the island’s mythology, portraying it as a living, breathing ecosystem where Kong maintains the balance between nature and the other monstrous inhabitants. The Skullcrawlers, for example, represent a chaotic force that Kong must keep at bay to preserve the island’s harmony.
See also: Is Kong Skull Island A Remake? [Revealed]
The Tone and Style of the Films
Another key difference between King Kong (2005) and Kong: Skull Island is their tone and style.
King Kong (2005)
Peter Jackson’s King Kong is an epic, sprawling film that focuses on spectacle and emotion. The film is nearly three hours long, with elaborate set pieces, detailed character development, and emotional moments, especially between Kong and Ann Darrow. Jackson’s love for the original King Kong is evident in every frame. The film mixes adventure, romance, and tragedy, with a grandiose visual style that emphasizes Kong’s scale and power.
Kong: Skull Island (2017)
In contrast, Kong: Skull Island has a faster pace and a more action-oriented tone. The film doesn’t dwell on the emotional depth of its characters in the same way that Jackson’s film does. Instead, it emphasizes action, adventure, and spectacle. The battle scenes between Kong and the island’s creatures are fast-paced and intense, and the film’s lighter tone and occasional humor differentiate it from the more somber tone of King Kong (2005).
Kong’s Characterization: Tragic Hero vs. Powerful Protector
Kong is portrayed differently in each film.
In King Kong (2005), he is a tragic figure. His existence on Skull Island is marked by isolation, fear, and loneliness. His brief bond with Ann Darrow gives him a glimpse of connection and understanding, but it also leads to his downfall. His death atop the Empire State Building is heartbreaking, marking him as a symbol of misunderstood nature destroyed by human ambition.
In Kong: Skull Island, Kong is more of a protector and ruler. He is not a tragic figure, but a king defending his domain from external threats. He does not form a deep emotional bond with the human characters, but he is shown to have a sense of justice and duty toward the creatures he protects. The film presents him as a force of nature, one that commands respect rather than sympathy.
Visual Effects and Technological Advances
The technological advancements between the two films are also worth noting.
Peter Jackson’s King Kong relied on groundbreaking CGI technology at the time to bring the character to life. Kong’s facial expressions, emotions, and physical presence were carefully crafted using motion-capture technology, with actor Andy Serkis providing the performance behind the character. The film’s visual effects were praised for their detail and realism, making Kong a believable and sympathetic character.
Kong: Skull Island benefited from further advancements in CGI technology. The visual effects in this film are stunning, especially in the action sequences where Kong battles other giant creatures. The 2017 film also embraces a more vibrant color palette, particularly during the island’s more chaotic moments. This gives Kong: Skull Island a distinct visual style that sets it apart from the darker and more muted tones of King Kong (2005).
Conclusion
So, are King Kong (2005) and Kong: Skull Island related? The answer is no, they are not connected in terms of story or cinematic universe. Peter Jackson’s King Kong is a standalone retelling of the classic story, paying homage to the original film while exploring themes of beauty, tragedy, and the destructive power of human ambition. Kong: Skull Island, on the other hand, is part of Legendary’s MonsterVerse, positioning Kong as a key player in a larger narrative that involves other famous monsters like Godzilla.
Both films, however, share common elements: they both explore the mystery and danger of Skull Island, and they both portray Kong as a powerful and iconic creature. Despite their differences, both movies contribute to the ongoing legacy of King Kong as one of cinema’s most enduring and beloved characters.
In the end, whether you prefer the tragic grandeur of Peter Jackson’s King Kong or the action-packed adventure of Kong: Skull Island, both films offer unique and compelling takes on the legendary ape.
Related topic:
How Many Versions of King Kong Are There?
Who Voices King Kong In The Mario Movie?